Meaningful Consumption – Consumer Behavior Concepts and Applications by Aditya Gupta * [46]

 

What makes a purchase meaningful? Reflect on the things you spent money on recently. Perhaps, bar tabs, gas, groceries, rent/mortgage, takeout boxes, Starbucks and Ubers? While some of these purchases were made from sheer necessity (you need a roof over your head), others were made for pleasure (a Frappuccino on a broiling summer day? Yes please!). But how many (if any) of these transactions would you classify as meaningful?

For the longest time, consumer behavior researchers have invested considerable effort in understanding what makes a purchase useful (the utilitarian perspective) and what makes it pleasurable (the hedonic perspective). In contrast, there’s been scant research on what makes certain purchases – i.e., the products, services, and experiences we buy– meaningful to us. The research I undertook with my colleagues enables me to answer the question as follows: 

Ø     > A purchase is perceived as personally, deeply, and enduringly meaningful if it can enable at least one of three key experiences: rejuvenation, expansion, and consolidation.

The question of meaningfulness arises from a third perspective, eudaimonia. Introduced by Aristotle’s writings, eudaimonia explains how to lead a virtuous, purposeful, meaningful life. These days we see several related concepts in popular culture – flow, flourishing, holistic well-being, and self-expression. Meaningfulness is one of these facets and, as I describe below, it is possible to find through the time, effort, and money spent by consumers. There are three key themes associated with meaningful consumption: rejuvenation, expansion, and consolidation.

      1. Rejuvenation

Consumers are likely to find a purchase meaningful if it can provide a sense of renewal to them. This can happen in two ways: repair and reconnection. The key idea underlying repair is one of escape and healing from the stressors and strains of modern life. Whether it was a vacation getaway or a daily retreat to the gym, people valued experiences that enabled a temporary relief from the many demands of day-to-day life and allowed them to rest and recharge their batteries. In contrast, the central idea behind reconnection was about renewing relationships. People spoke fondly of annual reunions and basketball game tickets because those experiences were instrumental in helping them keep integral ties of family and friendship alive.

2. Expansion 

Many of us are likely to start finding life dull if there are no new horizons to explore. We saw several examples of how consumers would often seek out intellectual, pragmatic, or relational expansion. Simply put, consumers find meaning in purchases that enable them to broaden their intellectual horizons, learn or sharpen a skill, or forge new relationships. People enthusiastically recounted finding meaning through purchases of books on topics they were interested in, DIY furniture that they learned how to assemble, and thoughtful presents for loved ones as a way of building relationships. As can be seen, the central idea underlying expansion is that of growth, and purchases which can help bring that into consumers’ lives are more likely to end up being meaningful to them.

3. Consolidation

The final experience linked to meaningful consumption tries to capture how certain purchases lead to a deeper and richer understanding of who we are and the larger world we inhabit. We term the former crystallization and the latter contextualization. Much as how crystals form through a slow process of solidification, certain purchases lead consumers toward a better understanding of their own selves, strengths, weaknesses, and achievements. In essence, such purchases helped consumers to better crystallize their own sense of self. In contrast to this relatively more inward perspective, examples of contextualization underscored a more outward perspective as seen in certain purchases which allowed consumers to get a stronger grasp on their position relative to the larger contextual aspects of their existence such as the passage of time, the world they lived in, and even the cosmos. Several such examples originated, perhaps naturally, from experiences during travel. People recalled how visiting now-defunct mining caves gave them an eerie inkling of what life must have been like for miners who used to work there many decades ago. Others spoke of how seeing a rapidly diminishing glacier made climate change that much more vivid to them. Given how a lot has been written about how many of us wish to move toward a greater understanding of ourselves and our place in the world, it was no surprise that such purchases ended up resulting in cherished memories because of their consolidative nature.

Marketers Can Create Superior Value and Deliver Meaningful Consumer Experiences

Services (e.g., bike rentals, gyms, higher education, restaurants, spas) and experiences (e.g., amusement parks, concerts, marathons, theaters, travel packages) lend themselves well to building meaningful consumption. Such marketing applications imply that there will be active buyer involvement and co-creation of value opportunities. A great example of this is the tremendous success of Airbnb vacation rentals which disrupted the hotel sector. Under its ambit, a wide variety of meaningful classes/workshops, walking/food and wine-tasting tours, and interesting or exotic trips are offered to consumers worldwide.

You will find rejuvenation, expansion, and/or consolidation and breathe a sigh of relief as you get away from the office for a few days.  Perhaps, learn candle-making or glass-blowing or be inspired by the splendor of a natural wonder at the end of a hiking trail.

Companies should consider revising their value propositions to go beyond utility and pleasure motivations. To what extent can your company provide meaningful consumption experiences for their target markets? Goods, services, and ideas can be redesigned/ repositioned to increase the likelihood of customers finding your products truly meaningful. In turn, such gratitude will be highly rewarded with increased loyalty, word-of-mouth/word-of-mouse promotion, and enhanced business performance.

*Aditya Gupta, Ph.D., is an Assistant Professor of Marketing at Illinois State University. He may be reached at agupt16@ilstu.edu

1. 

3    

Using Mobile Devices in the Retail Store by Suri Weisfeld-Spolter * [10]

Use of mobile devices has become commonplace for contemporary retail shoppers.  At their fingertips, consumers can easily obtain lots of information to aid their shopping efforts and decisions. This phenomenon has been a challenge for some marketers; for others, a benefit.  For instance, brick-and-mortar retailers have announced store closings (e.g., Macy’s in 2016 and early 2017), dissolution (e.g., Limited’s elimination of its store format in 2016 ), or corporate layoffs (e.g., WalMart in 2017), as their financial metrics are upended through e-commerce. At the same time, e-tailers have parlayed their technological competencies to embrace technologically-savvy buyers. Witness Alibaba’s acute aspirations to become a worldwide e-marketer and Amazon’s tremendous expansion of the breadth and depth of its offerings as well as recent establishment of its own global delivery service.

Retail salespeople have traditionally been providers of information for customers. Indeed, until the advent and enormous growth of the internet and e-commerce, sales personnel tended to be the primary purveyors of information in selling.  As noted above, however, the retailing dynamic has changed markedly. Many retail customers now turn increasingly to marshaling information from alternative sources—particularly from mobile devices. In fact, consumers seem to be replacing traditional retail salesperson functions—such as collecting information, comparing prices, and securing the order—with mobile devices. This situation may well foreshadow a decline in the importance of salespersons in buyer-seller interactions.

Interestingly, a consumer’s mobile device is somewhat similar to retail salesperson input in that it mimics the personal nature of selling. Accordingly, many of today’s consumers tend to consult their smartphone rather than interact with retail sales personnel. Indeed, 73% of shoppers would rather use their phones than deal with the salesperson. 

With increasing consumer preference for mobile devices for both hedonic and utilitarian reasons and avoidance of the retail salesperson, we did a study to explore the consumer’s information search behavior vis-à-vis the salesperson’s selling behavior so as to enhance understanding of how retail salespeople can influence mobile dependent shoppers.

We found that the more searching consumers do on their phones, the more they experience increases in perceived control, which fosters their purchase intention. These findings suggest that retailers should create an environment that facilitates feelings of perceived control because that construct is closely connected to the pathway between search and purchase intention. For example, providing consumers with easy access to free wi-fi in stores is one technique to help create a shopping environment that nurtures mobile phone searching. Retailers might also adopt a selling philosophy that helps consumers in their role as search agents to perceive that they are controlling the interaction with the salesperson (e.g., “Come to our store and be the boss,” “We don’t push you; you are in charge”). Because the mobile phone seems to increase feelings of control, retailers should also assist consumers to stay connected to their phone so that they can continue to search in the store. Furthermore, salespeople should be trained to be search assistants for the customers rather than assume the traditional role of “pushing the sale.” In this context, retail salespeople could assist consumers in their search activities by providing comparison websites, review sites, and alternative search terms. In a similar way, companies can create apps for the mobile phone to engage consumers while in the store, and salespeople can direct them to download these applications. 

* Suri Weisfeld-Spolter, Ph.D., is a Professor of Marketing at Nova Southeastern University. She can be reached at sw887@nova.edu  This post is based on her journal article in Psychology & Marketing titled, “Under the sway of a mobile device during an in-store shopping experience”.

Ethnographic Research Uncovers What Customers Value by Herb Brotspies * [7]

Now, more and more marketers are turning to ways to find what customers value—why consumers buy the products they do, how they use them, and importantly, how they relate to products in ways big data or conventional market research surveys cannot.  They are increasingly using techniques used by anthropologists called ethnographic research, studying consumers where they live, where they work, in the kitchen, in the bathroom, in the stores, restaurants, concerts, malls, or college campuses.  This observational method helps marketers by showing how products are used, the meaning of products in their lives, and the lifestyles that influence purchase decisions. 

Ethnography evaluates consumer behavior in detail, identifying important patterns through observation of people engaging in activities such as browsing, buying and trying products, or using services.  Based on ethnographic findings of consumer value, recommendations are made to conduct quantified market research, develop new products, add features to existing products, or change advertising approaches.

Intel, the computer chip maker, uses ethnographic research to understand how teenagers, who grew up with smart phones, use their devices differently than baby boomers, how television and PC technology converge, and how smart phones are taking over most of the functions of personal computers.  J.C. Penney looks in women’s closets to see the brands and styles of clothing they purchase for work.  Clairol, the marketer of hair coloring, watches how women apply hair coloring at home to improve the ease of product use.

5 Ethnographic Case Summaries by Consumer Research Associates

> Abbvie Pharmaceuticals, a marketer of a drug for HIV, wanted to understand the patient journey to identify opportunities for innovation in packaging, messaging, and service.  Researchers observed physicians with patients and conducted in-home interviews with patients to learn how drugs are used.  As a result of the research, new techniques were developed to help patients comply with their therapies and to help physicians communicate and personalize treatment solutions for patients.  
> Miller Lite wanted to understand how brand updates would be received and understood by their current customers.  Researchers conducted in-home qualitative studies to gauge user reaction to marketing ideas being considered.  Interviews were conducted in stores and bars with different brand concepts in a natural setting to gauge consumer reaction.   Using a variety of ethnographic methods, the project culminated in the successful update of all Miller Lite branding and marketing materials.
> Best Buy, a leading consumer electronics retailer, wanted to explore expanding its selection to include a health and fitness department.  They were interested in how well customers would accept this brand expansion with a particular appeal to female shoppers. They wanted to understand the consumer product research and decision-making processes and to identify value triggers for investing in home fitness equipment. Ethnographers collected stories among women who recently purchased fitness equipment learning about stores the participants liked including Best Buy.  Researchers accompanied consumers on shopping trips for fitness equipment to understand the purchase process.  The ethnographic research helped Best Buy design the fitness department and provided direction in product selection.
> Ethnographic research is also useful in business-to-business situations.  Bosch, a manufacturer of production equipment, wanted to determine how to gain a competitive advantage over rival companies.  They first conducted interviews with production managers and then went into the manufacturing plant to observe how production-line staff used competitive equipment.  The observations revealed there were customer needs that were missed by competitors such as awkward adjustments and difficult maintenance procedures.  The result was a line of Bosch manufacturing products that overcame the shortcomings of competitive products.  Observing the use of competitive products, an ethnographic technique, gave Bosch the market insight they needed.
> Miele, a German household products company, wanted to investigate the cleaning needs of people with allergies.  They sent researchers into homes of people who had children with allergies to observe cleaning practices.  Through ethnographic research, they discovered, parents spent extra time vacuuming mattresses to remove allergens.  Parents could not be sure the mattresses were allergen- free, so they kept vacuuming.  Miele developed a vacuum cleaner with a series of lights that indicated when the item is dust-free.  This reduced the time and uncertainty of parents vacuuming their child’s bed, adding value consumers desired.  Based on this research, Miele also introduced a washing machine with special features to thoroughly clean pillows and bedding of allergens.

Big data, finding unusual relationships in structured and unstructured data, will always play an important part in marketing to understand what is happening.  But to develop insight as to uncovering consumer value, marketers use ethnographic research and visit people in their homes, watch how they use products, listen to stories about how and why they buy, what they buy, and gain deep insight into the purchase decisions. 
Perhaps, you should incorporate ethnography into your marketing research toolbox?  

* Herb Brotspies is an Adjunct Professor of Marketing (Retired) at Nova Southeastern University. For further information, contact Dr. Brotspies at hvb95@aol.com or (561) 302-3060.